Alternative Regulation

Synapse is actively engaged in alternative regulatory proceedings across the country. We strive to establish frameworks that encourage utilities to innovate, operate more efficiently, and achieve public policy goals without inappropriately shifting risk to customers.

Overview

We provide policy guidance regarding alternative regulatory structures including:

  • Performance-Based Regulation (PBR), 
  • Multi-Year Rate Plans (MRP), 
  • Performance Incentive Mechanisms (PIM), and 
  • Revenue decoupling.

Performance-Based Regulation, Multi-Year Rate Plans, and Performance Incentives

Comprehensive performance-based regulation plans include both multi-year rate plans and performance incentive mechanisms, all of which must be designed carefully to avoid shifting risk to utility customers. We work with our clients to identify the existing incentives that utilities face under the current regulatory framework, determine areas where performance could be improved, and propose creative solutions that deliver net benefits to customers while avoiding perverse incentives.  We use a variety of in-house economic, financial, and statistical models to evaluate the impacts of utility proposals on customers, review the cost-effectiveness of various performance incentive mechanisms, and evaluate the financial implications associated with various utility cost recovery mechanisms.  

Our work in this area includes:

  • Evaluating whether alternative regulatory frameworks are appropriate
  • Ensuring that regulated utilities are provided with meaningful financial incentives to reduce costs and increase efficiency through well-designed multi-year rate plans
  • Assessing and designing performance metrics and incentives to encourage utilities to meet public policy goals such as resilience and decarbonization cost-effectively
  • Proposing mechanisms to address the needs of low-income customers and support diverse energy resources such as energy efficiency and distributed generation
     

Revenue Decoupling

Revenue decoupling mechanisms sever the link between utility sales and revenues, meaning utilities no longer have to sell more and more electricity or gas to increase their profit. This reduces the financial disincentive that utilities experience regarding energy efficiency and other demand-side resources. Although decoupling mechanisms are an important tool in enabling broader implementation of demand-side resources, they can be designed in many ways. If not designed well, decoupling mechanisms can work against customers’ interests.

Synapse provides technical and policy support regarding revenue decoupling mechanisms, including providing recommendations regarding:

  • Full versus partial revenue decoupling
  • Revenue-per-customer approaches
  • Caps on annual reconciliations
  • Adjustments to a utility’s allowed return on equity to reflect changes in the utility’s risk profile
  • Modifications to revenue targets between rate cases